Ultimate Showdown: All in One WP Migration vs. Duplicator – Which Plugin Reigns Supreme?

Managing WordPress sites often requires moving, backing up, or cloning them for testing purposes.

Whether you’re changing hosting providers, setting up a staging environment, or simply want reliable backups, choosing the right plugin can streamline the process significantly.

In discussions about these tasks, two plugins frequently emerge: Duplicator and All in One WP Migration.

Both plugins claim to facilitate WordPress migrations and backups, but they employ different methods to achieve this.

We have utilized Duplicator for our projects and those of our partners, but we recognize that what suits our needs may not be ideal for everyone.

To address this, we conducted a side-by-side comparison of both plugins in various scenarios, ranging from simple blogs to intricate eCommerce platforms. Here’s what we learned about their advantages, drawbacks, and the specific situations where each excels.

Comparing All in One WP Migration and Duplicator: A Summary

All in One WP Migration and Duplicator are both well-regarded WordPress backup and migration plugins, each offering distinct features. For a quick comparison of their main attributes, we’ve prepared a table.

We encourage you to continue reading for a comprehensive analysis of each tool. This will help you make an informed decision for your WordPress website’s backup and migration requirements.

Comparing All in One WP Migration and Duplicator

To provide a complete and unbiased comparison of these WordPress backup plugins, we created multiple demo websites to install and evaluate both tools. This enabled us to explore their features, user interfaces, and overall performance in various scenarios.

We thoroughly assessed each plugin’s backup capabilities, focusing on the available features and user-friendliness. We then imported these backup files into different demo websites to evaluate the restoration process.

This analysis helped us evaluate the performance of each plugin in real-world migration situations. During our testing, we meticulously documented our observations, highlighting both successful aspects and areas for improvement.

We have relied on Duplicator for many years in our projects and tutorials. This extensive experience has provided us with a comprehensive understanding of its features and performance across various scenarios.

To delve deeper into our insights, feel free to check out our detailed review of Duplicator.

We have also utilized All in One WP Migration for our own research, which has given us valuable hands-on experience with both tools.

In our assessment, we took into account not only the plugins themselves but also how different users might benefit from their unique features. While all backup plugins operate on similar principles, we acknowledged that certain functionalities may cater better to specific user needs.

For instance, beginners may prefer an all-in-one backup plugin that is user-friendly, while advanced users might seek greater control and customization options for their backups, including features like multisite support.

With this background, let’s dive into a comparison of All in One WP Migration and Duplicator. You can use the quick links below to jump to the section that interests you the most:

Export and Backup Features

A strong export and backup feature is essential in a migration plugin. It’s not only about speed but also about flexibility and dependability.

We have combined the concepts of export and backup because, in the context of migration plugins, they typically refer to the same action: creating a portable version of your website. Let’s examine how All in One WP Migration and Duplicator approach this essential function.

All in One WP Migration: User-Friendly Yet Robust

All in One WP Migration provides impressive export capabilities, even in its free version.

Upon accessing the export page, you’ll discover more than just a backup option. There’s also a convenient search and replace feature for the database. You can perform multiple search and replace actions, which is beneficial when updating URLs or other site-specific information during the migration process.

Additionally, we appreciate that you can secure your entire WordPress backup file with a password. This feature enhances security, particularly when storing backups in shared environments or transmitting them over unsecured networks.

Moreover, the plugin allows you to customize your export with various options. You can choose to exclude elements such as spam comments, post revisions, or the media library.

These options provide you with detailed control over your backup, which can be advantageous in various scenarios. For instance, omitting the media library can significantly reduce the file size if your site contains numerous images.

It’s important to note that beginners may find some features unclear at first. For example, the advantages of the search and replace feature for the database might not be immediately apparent.

We believe the plugin could improve by providing clearer explanations of these advanced options directly within the interface. For newcomers, the value of the ‘Find and Replace’ feature in the database isn’t obvious, and in-plugin tips would be beneficial.

After setting everything up, you can export your site as a .wpress file, which the plugin utilizes for both exporting and importing.

To export to FTP, cloud storage, or enable automatic backups, you will need to purchase an extension.

Duplicator: A Complete Backup Solution

Duplicator matches All in One WP Migration in terms of export and backup capabilities.

Similar to its competitor, you can back up your site and store it on your WordPress hosting for free, then download the files to your computer.

With Duplicator, you can back up your entire website—including the database, plugins, themes, and more—or just the database. The database-only option is useful if you’re primarily concerned about content changes and don’t frequently need to back up static files.

For backups that focus solely on the database, you can apply filters to exclude specific tables. This feature is beneficial for reducing the size of your backup or omitting unnecessary data.

We also appreciated that Duplicator allows you to exclude particular WordPress files, folders, or file types from the backup. This is ideal for omitting large files you don’t need or sensitive information you prefer to keep private.

Similar to All in One WP Migration, Duplicator provides password protection for your backups, enhancing the security of your WordPress site.

While these features may appear daunting for beginners, Duplicator has made efforts to simplify the experience. Helpful information buttons are available next to certain features, which display detailed explanations when hovered over.

This user-friendly design helps newcomers easily comprehend and utilize the plugin’s more advanced functionalities.

One feature we truly value is Duplicator’s pre-backup scan. It thoroughly checks your entire WordPress site before creating a backup to ensure everything is functioning properly. This helps avoid incomplete or faulty backups, saving you time and potential issues down the line.

Once the backup is complete, you will receive a zip file containing your archive along with an installer file.

For larger websites, Duplicator recommends using its unique DupArchive format. This format is specifically designed to bypass limitations often imposed by budget hosting providers, allowing you to create larger backups without encountering server problems.

Similar to All in One WP Migration, the premium version of Duplicator allows you to export to FTP or cloud storage and includes automatic backup options.

However, Duplicator takes it a step further by allowing you to designate a backup as a disaster recovery point. This feature is invaluable for quickly restoring your site to a previously known good state in case of issues, especially if you are locked out of your WordPress admin dashboard.

Winner: Duplicator

After a thorough comparison of both plugins, we believe Duplicator has a slight advantage over All in One WP Migration when it comes to exports and backups.

While both plugins offer robust features, Duplicator’s pre-backup scan, versatile backup options, and its unique DupArchive format for larger websites provide it with a competitive edge. The disaster recovery point feature in the premium version is particularly beneficial for site owners who require fast recovery solutions.

Import/Restore Features

Once you have backed up or exported your WordPress site, the next step is to import it. Let’s explore how these WordPress migration plugins manage this process.

All in One WP Migration: Effortless Drag and Drop

To get started with All in One WP Migration, first install the plugin through your WordPress admin dashboard.

Once installed, you can easily import your backup file by simply dragging and dropping it. This user-friendly process allows for quick restoration or migration of your WordPress site.

The plugin provides additional import options, including FTP, server transfer, URL, and cloud storage, along with a one-click restore feature accessible from the plugin’s backup page.

However, some of these features require purchasing separate paid extensions.

A significant limitation of the free version is the file upload size restriction, which is often determined by your web hosting server settings, typically capping uploads at 256 MB or less.

If your backup file exceeds this limit, you’ll need to purchase the Unlimited extension to import it successfully.

The Unlimited license eliminates this limitation, making it a valuable option if you frequently migrate your site or manage larger WordPress installations.

During our tests, we successfully transferred our WordPress site to a new host, but encountered timeout errors when attempting to import it on a local WordPress setup on a computer.

This issue can occur with local server environments, so it’s something to keep in mind if you intend to set up a local staging site.

Duplicator: Versatile Restoration Features

Duplicator offers a unique method for importing and restoring your site.

In the free version, you utilize the installer file downloaded during the backup process. You upload this file to your WordPress directory using a file manager or FTP client, then go tohttps://yourdomain.com/installer.php.

This launches a user-friendly restoration wizard that assists you throughout the process.

This approach is effective whether you are restoring a backup on the same site or migrating to a new hosting provider with a different domain.

It is indeed a bit more hands-on compared to All in One WP Migration’s method. Before starting, you need to create a new, empty database on your hosting account.

This step is done in your web hosting control panel (such as cPanel). It may seem technical initially, but it typically requires just a few clicks. Once you have the database name and user set up, the Duplicator installer wizard will guide you through the remaining steps.

One of the main benefits of this method is that there are no upload size restrictions. Additionally, you do not need to install WordPress or the Duplicator plugin beforehand, making it perfect for setting up a new site or working in a local development environment.

Upgrading to one of Duplicator’s pro plans unlocks a range of user-friendly features. These include one-click database restoration, comprehensive backups, drag-and-drop file imports through the plugin interface, and the ability to import files via URL or cloud storage.

A key feature of Duplicator Pro is its disaster recovery restoration capability.

You can either copy a recovery link to save it outside your WordPress site or download a launcher file. This launcher is an HTML file that initiates the recovery wizard, allowing you to quickly restore your site if you lose access to your WordPress admin.

Duplicator excels at migrating a live website to a local environment. We were able to create a comprehensive tutorial on how to transfer a live WordPress site to a local server, thanks to its reliable performance in this area.

Winner: Duplicator

In our view, Duplicator leads in the import and restore category.

All in One WP Migration features a user-friendly drag-and-drop interface. However, Duplicator’s unlimited file size in the free version and its more adaptable restoration process provide it with a significant advantage.

The premium version offers one-click restoration and unique disaster recovery features, enhancing its effectiveness. For users with larger websites or those needing advanced restoration capabilities, Duplicator provides a more robust solution.

Integrations for Remote Storage

Both All in One WP Migration and Duplicator include cloud storage integrations in their premium plans. This feature enables you to connect these WordPress backup plugins to various providers for securely storing your website files.

This capability is especially beneficial when migrating a WordPress site or creating off-site backups. Let’s explore how these WordPress migration plugins stack up against each other regarding remote storage options.

All in One WP Migration: Wide Range of Options with Individual Paid Extensions

All in One WP Migration boasts an impressive array of remote storage integrations. It supports 15 different providers, including popular choices like FTP, Dropbox, Google Drive, Amazon S3, and OneDrive, along with less common options such as pCloud and WebDAV.

Connecting to most of these extensions is simple. For instance, to back up your WordPress site to Google Drive, just link your Google Drive account, and the plugin will automatically create a backup folder in your Drive.

One drawback is that these integrations are offered as separate extensions. This is manageable if you only require one storage provider, but if you need multiple options, you’ll have to buy additional extensions.

Duplicator: Limited Options but Comprehensive Solution

While Duplicator supports fewer storage providers than All in One WP Migration, it still includes major options such as Amazon S3, Google Drive, Dropbox, Microsoft OneDrive, and FTP/SFTP.

Additionally, it is compatible with any S3-Compatible Cloud Storage, which broadens its usability.

The setup process with Duplicator is a bit more complex. For instance, to back up your site to Dropbox, you must connect the plugin to Dropbox and insert a code snippet into your plugin, adding an extra step.

The main distinction is that all Duplicator plans come with these integrations included, eliminating the need to purchase separate extensions for each storage provider you wish to use.

Result: Draw

It is challenging to declare a clear winner as both plugins have unique advantages. All in One WP Migration provides a broader selection of storage options, offering users greater flexibility in choosing where to save their WordPress backups.

In contrast, Duplicator’s comprehensive approach provides access to all supported integrations with any paid plan, potentially making it a more economical choice compared to purchasing cloud storage extensions for All in One WP Migration.

Ultimately, the ideal choice between these WordPress backup plugins will depend on your individual storage requirements and budget.

Feature Variety

Both All in One WP Migration and Duplicator come equipped with a variety of features that extend beyond basic backup and migration, enhancing their value as complete WordPress migration solutions. Let’s delve into the offerings of each plugin.

All in One WP Migration: Flexible Structure with Paid Add-ons

Here’s a comprehensive list of features available in All in One WP Migration when you upgrade from the free version and utilize paid add-ons:

• One-click backup restoration
• Unlimited use on websites you own
• Elimination of the 256 MB upload limit
• Integrated search and replace functionality
• Backup scheduling options with hourly, daily, and weekly intervals
• Cloud storage integration with over 15 providers
• Reset tools to restart your WordPress site
• Support for multisite installations
• WP CLI commands for advanced users
• Premium customer support

It’s important to note that certain features, such as cloud storage integration, multisite support, and scheduled backups, are only offered as paid add-ons. You’ll need to purchase these separately to unlock the complete range of functionalities.

Duplicator: Extensive Features Included in All Paid Plans

Here’s a summary of the features included in Duplicator’s paid plans:

• Automatic backup scheduling with options for hourly, daily, and weekly intervals
• More than 5 cloud backup storage options
• Easy drag-and-drop import functionality
• Migration wizard for seamless website transfers
• Email notifications for backup issues
• Disaster recovery points for quick restoration
• Backup limits to optimize storage management
• Server-to-server import capabilities
• Support for managed hosting environments
• Compatibility with shared databases
• Support for multisite configurations
• Advanced user permission settings for backup files
• Custom branding options for installers

Keep in mind that some features, such as multisite support, advanced user permissions, and custom installer branding, are only available in higher-tier plans. These features are primarily designed for professionals managing multiple clients and websites.

Conclusion: Duplicator is the winner

We believe Duplicator surpasses All in One WP Migration in this area.

According to the feature comparison, Duplicator provides a more extensive range of tools in its premium plans. Its support for large sites, disaster recovery options, and advanced migration features across all paid tiers make Duplicator a highly adaptable solution.

Plugin Support

Dependable support can greatly enhance your experience with WordPress migration plugins, particularly when you’re working to migrate your site securely.

This section evaluates the support services provided by All in One WP Migration and Duplicator.

All in One WP Migration: Comprehensive Support with Extended Availability

All in One WP Migration provides various support options to assist users with their WordPress backup and migration requirements. You can reach out to them via their WordPress.org support page, where users can ask questions and receive community support.

For more detailed information, they have a knowledge base filled with useful articles and guides. We found many of these articles beneficial when we were exploring the plugin’s features.

All in One WP Migration offers paid users the option to submit support tickets. Their support team is available during extended hours, operating on weekdays from 8 AM to 10 PM (UTC+7) and on weekends from 9 PM to 6 AM (UTC+7).

Duplicator: Diverse Support Options with Weekday Availability

Duplicator features a comprehensive knowledge base that addresses various aspects of using the plugin for WordPress backups and migrations.

Users can also find assistance through the WordPress.org support page, where they can engage with the community and the plugin’s support team.

For those interested in purchasing Duplicator, a pre-sales form is available to address any questions prior to making a decision.

Paid users can directly submit support tickets to the Duplicator team, which strives to respond to all inquiries within 24 hours during weekdays, with support hours from Monday to Friday, 9 AM to 5 PM (UTC-5).

Winner: All in One WP Migration

The extended support hours, including weekend availability, make All in One WP Migration more accessible for users across various time zones and work schedules. This is crucial when migrating a WordPress site or managing urgent backup issues.

Cost-Effective Solution

When selecting the best WordPress migration plugin, pricing is a crucial factor. We advise against spending excessively on a plugin that fails to fulfill your requirements, as well as opting for a low-cost solution that lacks essential features.

Let’s explore which plugin offers the best value for your investment.

All in One WP Migration: Versatile Yet Possibly Expensive

All in One WP Migration provides a free core plugin that includes basic export and import capabilities.

For advanced features such as one-click restoration, you’ll need the Unlimited extension, which costs $5.75 per month when billed annually or $69 per year.

Additionally, each cloud storage provider extension is priced at $99 per year, while the Multisite extension costs $319 per year.

A benefit is that the storage provider and Multisite extensions come with the Unlimited extension included, which can lead to cost savings.

However, expenses can accumulate rapidly. For example, if you require both Multisite support and a cloud storage option, your total could reach $418 per year.

All extensions allow for use on an unlimited number of websites and come with premium support, which is advantageous for managing multiple WordPress sites.

Duplicator: Comprehensive Features Available at Various Price Levels

The free version of Duplicator provides essential export and import capabilities through an installer file.

Their premium plans, however, offer a wide range of features at various price levels.

Duplicator Pro offers four subscription tiers: Basic ($49.50 annually), Plus ($99.50 annually), Pro ($199.50 annually), and Elite ($299.50 annually). All premium plans come with unlimited backups, migrations, support for multiple websites, compatibility with all cloud storage providers, disaster recovery points, and scheduled backups.

Additionally, the Pro and Elite tiers include support for Multisite. Therefore, for Multisite functionality and cloud storage, you would pay $199.50 or $299.50 per year, which is considerably more affordable than All in One WP Migration.or $299.50 per year, which is significantly less expensive than All in One WP Migration.

Winner: Duplicator

We believe Duplicator provides superior value for money, particularly for users requiring multiple features. It serves as a comprehensive WordPress backup solution that is more economical for most use cases.

While All in One WP Migration’s a la carte pricing allows for customization, it can quickly become costly when multiple features are needed.

All in One WP Migration vs Duplicator: Which Plugin Comes Out on Top?

After extensive testing of All in One WP Migration and Duplicator, we have determined that Duplicator is our top recommendation. It stands out as the best WordPress backup solution, providing an excellent mix of features, ease of use, and affordability.

However, All in One WP Migration is a great option for users seeking a simple and user-friendly tool for basic backups and migrations. Its free version is especially beneficial for small websites or infrequent migrations.

Below is a table summarizing the top performers for each criterion we evaluated:

As illustrated, Duplicator excels in most categories, making it our overall preferred choice.

We hope this article has provided you with valuable insights to compare All in One WP Migration and Duplicator. Additionally, you may want to explore our guide on connecting Google Drive to your WordPress media library and our expert recommendations for the best Dropbox plugins for WordPress.

If you enjoyed this article, consider subscribing to our YouTube Channel for valuable WordPress video tutorials. You can also connect with us on Twitter and Facebook.