Unlocking Revenue: Our Top 11 WordPress Paywall Plugins Reviewed (Free & Premium)

You’ve dedicated significant time and effort to producing high-quality content for your WordPress site, yet you’re offering it all for free. As your hosting expenses continue to rise, you’re likely seeking ways to monetize your expertise.

A paywall plugin may seem like the perfect solution, but many options are either overly complicated to configure or too simplistic to be useful. This could lead to paying subscribers unable to access their content, or worse, potential customers leaving due to a confusing paywall experience.

At CanadaCreate, we’ve evaluated numerous WordPress monetization tools and discovered that selecting the right paywall plugin can significantly impact your revenue.

In this article, we will present the 11 best WordPress paywall plugins (both free and premium) designed to help you safeguard your content, ensure a smooth user experience, and start generating income from your efforts without alienating your audience. 🙌

A Quick Overview: The Top WordPress Paywall Plugins

Looking for a summary? Here’s a brief introduction to each WordPress paywall plugin featured in this guide:

What Are WordPress Paywall Plugins?

A WordPress paywall plugin is a tool that allows you to monetize your website by restricting access to certain content. Visitors must pay or subscribe to bypass the paywall and access your premium posts and pages.

The terms ‘paywall plugin’ and ‘membership plugin’ are often used interchangeably. It’s useful to think of a paywall as a key feature of a membership plugin.ofa membership plugin.

While some basic tools only block content, most of the robust plugins on this list are comprehensive membership solutions. They not only create the paywall but also manage user accounts, process payments, and provide additional benefits like courses or private communities.

Consider websites like The New York Times or Patreon, where users subscribe to access exclusive articles or support creators in exchange for premium content.

Why Add a Paywall in WordPress?

Sometimes, you want to reserve your best content for your most dedicated paying customers.

Gating your content is one of the most effective strategies for generating revenue through blogging. However, paywalls are not exclusive to bloggers. Here are some other common applications:

• 🎙️ Content creators and podcasterscan restrict access to their most valuable media content, making it exclusive for paying subscribers.
• 🗞️ Digital publisherssuch as online newspapers and magazines can limit access to premium articles.
• 📚 Course creatorscan provide exclusive tutorials and educational content using paywall plugins.
• 🎨 Artists and photographerscan utilize paywall plugins to sell licenses for artwork, digital downloads, or high-resolution images.
• ℹ️ Freelancers and agenciescan charge for access to premium resources like templates or support materials.

A paywall is a monetization strategy that allows you to generate revenue from the valuable content you offer to your audience.

Additionally, it serves as an effective method to grow your email list, as you can require users to register for an account to access premium content.

Now, let’s explore the 11 top WordPress paywall plugins. Here’s a brief overview of what we will cover in this guide:

1. MemberPress – Ideal for Premium Memberships

MemberPress stands out as the top paywall plugin available. It’s an excellent choice if you operate a small business and are looking to offer exclusive content through a premium membership modelWe utilized this plugin to establish our video membership website, and our experience has been excellent.

For comprehensive insights into the capabilities of this plugin, refer to our detailed MemberPress review.

This plugin is equipped with a variety of features that enable you to create a paywall, manage content and memberships, and process recurring payments.

As the owner of the site, you control the rules for content access. You can schedule content releases based on specific timeframes and access expiration dates.

Releasing content on a set schedule keeps customers engaged, encouraging them to maintain their subscriptions for continuous access.

Additionally, you have the option to create multiple membership tiers.

Users can select their preferred plan, with each offering distinct content, pricing, and features. This allows you to design membership options that cater to various audiences, potentially increasing sales.

Within the MemberPress settings, you’ll discover additional useful features that can enhance conversion rates. For instance, you can set a limit on how many pages a visitor can view without a subscription.

This allows new visitors to sample your content and preview what they can expect from your premium offerings.

Additionally, we value the flexibility to set various rules, including content gating based on tags, categories, and other taxonomies.

Advantages of MemberPress:

• MemberPress is user-friendly and straightforward to navigate.
• It seamlessly integrates with a variety of third-party applications, including Drip, Constant Contact, Stripe, PayPal, and more.
• You have complete control over how to restrict content and establish different membership levels.

Disadvantages of MemberPress:

• While the free version is excellent for basic content restrictions, the Pro version is necessary for advanced functionalities like subscription billing, content dripping, and selling digital downloads.

Reasons to Choose MemberPress: With MemberPress, you can easily configure and restrict access to specific posts, pages, categories, and files exclusively for paying members. Based on our extensive research and testing, we have not encountered a paywall plugin that provides as many features.

Pricing Information: A free version of MemberPress is available, but you can upgrade to MemberPress Pro, starting at $179.50 per year.

2. MemberMouse – Ideal for Enterprise-Level Memberships

MemberMouse is one of the most intuitive paywall plugins available, and its advanced features make it robust enough for larger operations.high-quality membership websitesAlong with exclusive content, you can also offer unique physical products for sale.

To learn more about the features offered, please refer to our comprehensive MemberMouse review.

During our evaluation of this tool, we found it provides numerous options to enhance sales, including one-click upsells, free and paid trial periods, and exclusive pricing for members.

Additionally, you can control access to content by securing specific pages and posts, as well as automatically locking shared accounts. Similar to MemberPress, it allows you to implement custom content drip schedules and various membership tiers.

In summary, you have full control over content access and delivery.

For example, you can establish a tailored content drip schedule based on each membership tier. This strategy encourages subscribers to renew their memberships regularly.

Another impressive feature is the ability to create login forms, allowing users to easily sign in whenever they become members. MemberMouse generates custom HTML for each login form.

You can then incorporate that HTML into a custom sales or landing page created with a page builder plugin like SeedProd.

Advantages of MemberMouse:

• You can manage both subscription services and physical product sales from a single platform.
• The plugin integrates seamlessly with popular email marketing tools and payment processors.
• You can place the login form anywhere on your website, including landing pages.

Drawbacks of MemberMouse:

• There is no free version of this plugin available.

Reasons to Choose MemberMouse: We recommend MemberMouse for larger businesses and enterprises due to its robust features. It excels at creating paywalls, managing membership sites, and facilitating physical product sales.

Pricing Information: MemberMouse pricing starts at $149.50 per year.

3. WishList Member – Ideal for Detailed Control

WishList Member is a paywall plugin that enables you to offer premium content on your website with extensive control.This allows you to precisely manage when, who, and which content is accessible.

We conducted a comprehensive review of the plugin’s features, which you can find in our detailed WishList Member analysis.

WishList Member automatically grants and revokes access based on membership levels. Like other plugins, you can create multiple membership tiers.

Our testing revealed that you can automate content distribution by scheduling posts to be published at specific times and dates.

The ‘sneak peek’ feature is impressive and can significantly boost conversions by displaying snippets of gated content, enticing readers with a preview of what they could access.

WishList Member stands out as one of the few plugins that provides a Pay-per-Post option.

This allows users to purchase access to individual posts rather than relying solely on membership levels, enabling you to set unique prices for each post based on its perceived value.

One of the standout features of WishList Member is its extensive range of integrations, including numerous payment processors, email marketing platforms, and marketing automation tools.

For instance, if you’re a course creator or coach, you can seamlessly integrate this plugin with LearnDash or FunnelKit Automations to create a backend sales funnel for premium programs.

Advantages of WishList Member include:

• The ‘sneak peek’ feature allows you to showcase previews of gated content, which can help increase signups.
• It boasts an extensive library of integrations with various marketing and payment solutions.
• You have the option to restrict content by membership level or charge for access to individual posts.

Drawbacks of WishListMember:

• The interface may be somewhat complex for newcomers.

Reasons to Choose WishList Member: This paywall plugin is an excellent choice if you seek precise control over your content. Its standout feature is the ability to sell individual posts while still providing traditional membership options.

Cost: WishList Member is available for purchase starting at $149.50 per year.

4. Paid Memberships Pro – The Best Affordable Option

Paid Memberships Pro demonstrates that an effective paywall doesn’t have to be expensive. This freemium membership solution allows you to secure your content and charge for recurring subscriptions.

We have thoroughly tested this plugin to explore all its features, and you can read our comprehensive Paid Memberships Pro review for more information.

The free version of Paid Memberships Pro includes 28 different types of content restrictions.

For instance, you can limit access to a certain number of page views before reaching the paywall, provide sneak previews, or completely hide restricted content, as well as schedule access over time.

You can even create directories for viewing other member profiles or generate personalized content based on membership levels.

The premium version provides enhanced control and advanced features for better management.

The paid plans include premium customization options, enabling you to personalize your paywall’s appearance and functionality to meet your specific requirements. For instance, you can integrate a progress bar to display the amount of content a user has accessed or set up redirects for members upon logout based on their subscription level.

Moreover, you gain access to numerous add-ons such as Google Analytics, eCommerce tracking, premium customer support, advanced checkout page customizations, and much more.

Advantages of Paid Memberships Pro:

• The plugin is compatible with widely-used payment gateways.
• It offers valuable performance insights, including revenue and sales reports.
• You can enable users to buy one-time access to specific categories or individual posts.

Disadvantages of Paid Memberships Pro:

• It provides limited control over the actions members can perform in their account settings. For example, members cannot upgrade their plan without also being able to cancel it.

Reasons to Choose Paid Memberships Pro: We recommend Paid Memberships Pro because its free version is robust enough for initial use. If you wish to implement additional features, such as enhancing the checkout process or accepting donations, you can easily upgrade to the Pro version.

Pricing Information: Paid Memberships Pro starts at $174 annually, but a free version is available for download upon account registration.

5. Thrive Leads – The Best Paywall Plugin for Generating Leads

Thrive Leads is designed to transform website visitors into email subscribers.It includes various features such as pop-up lightboxes, sticky and floating bars, inline forms, and a paywall content lock..

For a detailed account of our testing experience, check out our comprehensive Thrive Themes Suite review.

The plugin features an intuitive drag-and-drop visual editor, enabling you to create customized opt-in forms. Additionally, it offers a wide selection of professionally designed templates to match your offer.

What we appreciate most about Thrive Leads is the option to gate your content through email opt-ins or by collecting payments.

To utilize Thrive Leads for paid content, you’ll need to integrate it with a payment processing and user access plugin, such as WooCommerce or Thrive Apprentice. You can include a link to your checkout page within the Thrive Leads form to guide users toward purchasing access.

Please note that Thrive Leads is available as a standalone plugin subscription or as part of the comprehensive Thrive Suite. For instance, with Thrive Apprentice, you can effortlessly establish a paywall and encourage your visitors to pay for access to your membership site.

Advantages of Thrive Leads:

• There are numerous professionally designed opt-in templates available for selection.
• You can integrate the content lock feature anywhere on your website.
• The plugin is user-friendly and straightforward to navigate.

Disadvantages of Thrive Leads:

• It requires an additional plugin, such as WPForms or WooCommerce, to process payment transactions.

Reasons to Choose Thrive Leads: When utilized as part of the complete Thrive Suite, you gain access to an all-in-one marketing toolkit. You can create landing pages, design opt-in forms, and manage conversions without depending on various third-party tools.

Pricing Information: Thrive Leads is priced at $99 per year. Alternatively, you can purchase the Thrive Suite bundle for $299 per year, which includes all Thrive products such as Thrive Leads, Thrive Ovation, Thrive Comments, and more.

6. OptinMonster – Ideal for ‘Subscribe Walls’

While many plugins on this list create paywalls for payment collection, OptinMonster stands out as our top choice for creating a subscription-based content barrier.The main objective is to expand your email list by concealing content until users register for your newsletter.

At CanadaCreate, we utilize OptinMonster and highly recommend it. For more details about the platform, check out our comprehensive review of OptinMonster.

OptinMonster’s content-lock feature integrates seamlessly with in-line campaigns, allowing you to place lead generation forms directly within your content.

With this functionality, you can either hide your premium content from view until the user subscribes or apply a blur effect to the content until they sign up.

Once the user submits their email, the locked content will become visible, enabling them to access your exclusive materials.

Additionally, similar to Thrive Leads, we value that OptinMonster enables the creation of captivating lead generation campaigns, including lightbox popups, slide-in scroll boxes, and full-screen welcome mats.

Advantages of OptinMonster:

• It is an effective method for building your email list.
• It offers a wide variety of templates and campaign formats, including popups, slide-ins, and more.
• You can choose to completely hide content or apply a blur effect to encourage users to subscribe.

Disadvantages of OptinMonster:

• This plugin is designed for lead generation and does not facilitate payment processing.

Reasons to Choose OptinMonsterIf your primary objective is to expand your email list by restricting access to content, OptinMonster is an excellent option. Although it doesn’t function as a traditional paywall for payment collection, it is one of the top tools for generating leads.

Pricing Information:OptinMonster pricing starts at $7 per month, or $59.60 per year when billed annually.

7. AccessAlly – The Best Paywall Plugin for Online Courses

AccessAlly is a learning management system (LMS) plugin. It offers various methods to create a paywall and manage recurring membership payments, making it ideal for coaches, trainers, and creators looking to sell courses through a membership model.

We have thoroughly tested its features and believe it is an excellent choice for implementing paywalls on WordPress blogs and websites.

In contrast to the typical paywall plugins listed here, AccessAlly aims to be a comprehensive platform that assists online coaches in crafting exceptional learning experiences.

This platform enables you to create a variety of digital offerings, including online courses, membership sites, certifications, premium coaching programs, community forums, and eBooks. It also provides templates for each type of campaign, allowing you to start quickly without building from scratch.

We appreciate the level of control you have over content protection. With access tags, you can effortlessly upload and secure files such as PDFs, MP3s, and more.

As a course creator, you can limit access to content based on membership levels or specific courses. The system uses tags and materials to ensure that only paying members can access certain content.

Additionally, AccessAlly allows you to hide protected content from Google search results, preventing unauthorized users from discovering your restricted paywall material.

Advantages of AccessAlly:

• You can oversee all your digital products, memberships, and gated content from a single dashboard.
• It seamlessly integrates with popular tools, including CRM applications and email marketing platforms.
• You can implement gamification elements to enhance user engagement by allowing them to earn points for completing tasks.

Disadvantages of AccessAlly:

• There is no free version offered.

Reasons to Choose AccessAlly: This robust plugin is ideal for content creators and online coaches. It allows you to safeguard your exclusive content, organize it into different membership levels, and process payments seamlessly with integrated Stripe and PayPal options.

Pricing Information: AccessAlly is available starting at $82 per year.

8. Restrict Content Pro – Outstanding Customer Dashboard

Restrict Content Pro is another excellent WordPress paywall plugin. We appreciate its intuitive customer dashboard and WooCommerce integration.

We thoroughly examined this plugin and tested all of its features. Our research revealed that it enables content restriction through various methods. You can restrict access using tags, content categories, membership levels, WordPress user roles, and more.

As previously mentioned, this tool simplifies account management for customers with its integrated dashboard. Members can check their account status, view membership expiration dates, upgrade or cancel their subscriptions, and access their complete payment history and past invoices.

Restrict Content Pro enables you to send automated and customizable emails to your subscribers. It includes tags for personalizing emails with details such as first and last names, expiration dates, coupon codes, and more.

The free version is available, but the Pro version provides enhanced features, including comprehensive earnings reports and the ability to offer free trials.

For those seeking a free tool, the lack of analytics may be a drawback, as these insights are vital for refining your sales strategies. Additionally, free trials can significantly help in converting leads.

Advantages of Restrict Content Pro:

• This plugin supports WooCommerce integration, enabling you to limit product purchases based on membership levels.
• You have multiple options for restricting access to your content.
• The Pro version allows you to provide free trials, which can enhance sales.

Disadvantages of Restrict Content Pro:

• Many advanced features, such as content dripping, free trials, and detailed reporting, are exclusive to the Pro version.

Reasons to Choose Restrict Content Pro:This tool features an excellent customer dashboard that allows users to easily manage their memberships. Additionally, its integration with WooCommerce makes it an ideal choice for online stores.

Pricing:Restrict Content Pro starts at $99 per year, with a free version available that lacks advanced features such as analytics and discount code support.

9. aMember Pro – Ideal for Multilingual Websites and Affiliate Marketing

aMember Pro is an easy-to-use paywall plugin designed for beginners, featuring advanced settings that are beneficial for expanding eCommerce sites. For instance, it enables you totranslate your website into various languagesand includes abuilt-in affiliate marketing program.

Similar to the other plugins on our list, aMember Pro allows users to create an unlimited number of membership levels. This feature enables you to sell restricted content at various price points and subscription plans.

Our tests also showed that the plugin allows you to create a dedicated members-only area. All content is accessible exclusively to members, ensuring that non-paying users cannot see what is available.

As previously mentioned, aMember Pro is distinguished by its support for multiple languages. You can effortlessly translate your content into any of its 22 supported languages.

Additionally, you gain access to advanced features such as customizable signup forms with automatic password generation and a built-in affiliate program.

We value the affiliate program feature, as it effectively encourages subscribers to promote your membership offerings.

Advantages of aMember Pro:

• You can establish your own affiliate program, comparable to a specialized plugin like AffiliateWP.
• The checkout process is highly customizable, featuring flexible signup forms, coupon codes, and more.
• The plugin provides precise control over content access for your users.

Disadvantages of aMember Pro:

• There is no free version available for this plugin.
• The user interface appears somewhat outdated.

Reasons to Choose aMember Pro:This plugin offers extensive customization options. You have detailed control over content delivery schedules, membership tiers, and which content to restrict. Additionally, it supports multiple languages and includes a built-in affiliate program.

Pricing Information:You can purchase aMember Pro for a one-time fee of $149.

10. LearnDash – Ideal for Advanced Online Courses

LearnDash is a widely-used WordPress LMS plugin, similar to AccessAlly, which we reviewed previously. However, it provides anadvanced custom course builderfor enhanced control. It’s an excellent option for anyone looking topaywall for online courses, quizzes, and lessons.

We tested all the features and you can read our detailed LearnDash review for more insights.

One of the standout features of LearnDash is its intuitive drag-and-drop editor, which allows you to create backend courses without any coding skills.

We appreciate that this learning management system offers much more than just a basic paywall; it includes extensive course-building tools for creating customized course content.

For instance, learners can only access the next module after completing the previous one, ensuring a structured and efficient learning experience.

Online learning can often feel monotonous, but with LearnDash, you can keep it engaging.

It enables you to maintain user interest by allowing the creation of private forums or membership quizzes. Additionally, you can award badges and certificates upon course completion.

Alongside these features, you can implement content restriction rules, such as requiring students to achieve a specific score by completing quizzes or reviewing prior articles in a series.

Advantages of LearnDash:

• It is a robust and versatile tool for selling online courses.
• It features numerous gamification elements to enhance user engagement.
• You have comprehensive control over how you limit access to your course materials.

Drawbacks of LearnDash:

• It functions as a complete Learning Management System (LMS), which might be excessive if you’re seeking a straightforward content paywall.

Reasons to Choose LearnDash: We recommend LearnDash because it offers a more interactive experience compared to a standard paywall. Rather than simply restricting content, it provides various ways to engage users, which is beneficial for fostering customer loyalty.

Pricing Information: LearnDash pricing plans begin at $199 per year.

11. WooCommerce Memberships – Ideal for WooCommerce Integration

WooCommerce Memberships is a robust extension that integrates seamlessly with WooCommerce. As indicated by its name, it is perfect for implementing a paywall for membership content in your WooCommerce store.

During our evaluation of WooCommerce Memberships, we found that it enables you to restrict services, products, and content exclusively to registered users. It is one of the few solutions that effectively combines your shop, content, and memberships.

Providing exclusive access to paying members fosters a close-knit community and enhances customer loyalty. WooCommerce Memberships facilitates this.

For instance, you might want to provide members with gifts and exclusive content. This feature enhances each membership plan with additional benefits beyond what a standard paywall plugin offers. You can even include free shipping for paid members.

Additionally, you can schedule content releases using WooCommerce Memberships.

Moreover, we particularly value its advanced control features. For example, the plugin allows you to restrict product visibility exclusively to members, ensuring that only they can access your top-tier, exclusive products.

This is especially effective if you are selling items through an auction plugin to manage limited stock.

Advantages of WooCommerce Memberships:

• You have numerous control options, such as limiting who can see specific products.
• The add-on enables you to provide free trials for memberships.
• You can release content to members according to a predetermined schedule.

Disadvantages of WooCommerce Memberships:

• It is specifically designed for WooCommerce store owners and requires the WooCommerce plugin to be installed.

Reasons to Choose WooCommerce Memberships:This plugin provides an excellent method to restrict content for store visitors. When customers pay to become members, they appreciate receiving additional benefits that are hard to find elsewhere.

Pricing Information: WooCommerce Memberships is available starting at $199 annually.

Which WordPress Paywall Plugin is the Best?

After evaluating numerous options, our top three recommendations are MemberPress, MemberMouse, and WishList Member.

For most users, MemberPress is the top choice. It provides a comprehensive suite of features for managing memberships and delivering content gradually, all within an intuitive interface suitable for small to medium-sized businesses.

If you operate a larger, enterprise-level website, MemberMouse is an outstanding choice. It includes advanced sales features such as one-click upsells and the capability to sell physical products alongside your digital offerings.

Lastly, WishList Member is perfect for those seeking maximum adaptability. Its distinctive Pay-per-Post feature allows for various monetization strategies beyond traditional subscriptions.

Common Questions About Paywall Plugins

As you explore paywall plugins, you might have some inquiries. Let’s address some frequently asked questions to assist you in selecting the best option for your WordPress site.

Is it possible to implement a paywall on WordPress?

To restrict access to your content on WordPress, you need a paywall plugin that allows you to limit visibility by page, post, category, and more. This ensures that visitors must take an action, such as creating an account or subscribing, to access the content.

Which paywall plugin is the best for WordPress?

The top choice for a paywall plugin is MemberPress. It features robust access rules that allow you to control content restrictions as needed. Additionally, you can schedule content delivery to members and even offer online courses.

What is the best free paywall plugin available for WordPress?

Paid Memberships Pro stands out as the best free paywall plugin. It provides various content restriction options for precise control over what users can access, and it supports recurring payment processing.

In what ways does a paywall generate revenue?

A paywall generates revenue by charging users for access to premium content. This can be achieved through subscription models, one-time fees, or membership charges. When users recognize the value of your content, they are more inclined to pay for it.

How successful are paywalls in generating revenue?

Paywalls can be highly effective, particularly for websites that provide unique and valuable content. They can create a consistent revenue stream, but their success largely depends on effective marketing and the perceived value of the content offered.

Essential Guides for Managing Memberships and User Permissions in WordPress

We hope this article has assisted you in selecting the ideal paywall plugin for your WordPress site.

You might also be interested in exploring our additional guides on:

• How to Create a Membership Site on WordPress
• How to Host Members-Only Events Using WordPress
• How to Require User Login to Access a Page in WordPress
• How to Limit User Login to a Single Device in WordPress
• How to Secure a Page or Post with a Password in WordPress
• Top WordPress Membership Plugins You Should Consider

If you enjoyed this article, please subscribe to our YouTube Channel for WordPress video tutorials. You can also connect with us on Twitter and Facebook.